The Supreme Council of Ethnic Hellenes (YSEE) has written a very good
presentation of the problem the Former Yugoslavian Republic of
Macedonia (FYROM) causes to Greece. FYROM is called Skopje by the Greeks
after its capital. Their language, which they call "Macedonian" is a Bulgarian dialect, which the Yugoslavians tried to make look Serbian as much as possible.
ABOUT MACEDONIA: HISTORY, PRESENT AND FUTURE
Press Release 345/15-1-2018
It
is by now well known that the Supreme Council of Ethnic Hellenes (YSEE)
is the organization representing the Hellenic Ethnic Religion and not a
political organization or party. For this reason it doesn't get
involved in political arguments nor does it partake in public debates
stemming from pseudo-ideological polarities such as left - right wing
politics, communism - fascism, nationalism - internationalism.
In
matters of major national importance, though, like the one about the
name of our neighboring country of Skopje, we are obligated to present
the historical aspects of the issue, calmly and prudently, contributing
in a solution that will not harm our national interests nor will it
undermine our territorial integrity and the welfare of our future
generations.
There
can be no debate about the Hellenic identity of the Macedonians simply
because the widespread Hellenization of the known world for at least two
centuries after the death of Alexander the Great had the Macedonians at
the forefront. This fact is well documented by numerous historical
sources as well as innumerable archaeological finds. Thus any attempt to
discuss the national character of the Macedonians under any pretenses
and by anyone is by default at least suspicious.
The
geographic area, that the whole debate is about, was named by the
Romans as Macedonia Secunda, after their conquest; in the same way they
named the entire Peloponnese as Achaea despite the fact that this was
especially insulting to the Spartans. This was done as a purely
administrative choice of a name for the wider area of modern day Skopje,
in a time when the Slavs were nowhere near the Balkan Peninsula.
In
the 19th century CE, while the Ottoman Empire was collapsing the
Orthodox Russians after the treaty of San Stefano in 1878, provocatively
pushed the creation of a Greater Bulgaria aiming to control the entire
Balkan Peninsula and the temperate waters of the Mediterranean. In this
Greater Bulgaria they incorporated areas of Macedonia that belong today
to Greece as well as areas that belong to Skopje and Bulgaria. In all of
these newly annexed areas preexisted strong and vibrant Greek
communities. With the consent of the Turks they created the Bulgarian
Exarchate in opposition to the Patriarchate and caused strife in the
population of the area, because those that followed the Exarchate were
considered automatically Bulgarian while those that remained with the
Patriarchate were thought to be Greeks. The Patriarchate of New Rome and
more so the Church of Greece which had its own shortsighted interests,
equated Hellenic identity to Orthodoxy, in an effort to retain its
influence on the populations of the area, managed to intensify the
conflicts by considering as Greeks only those that followed the
Patriarchate.
It
was during this time that the ideological construct of "Macedonianism"
which posits that the Macedonians are not Greeks, first appeared and the
dialect of the bilingual Macedonians was dubbed "Macedonian" language.
Even
after the Macedonian guerrilla clashes (1904-1908), the Balkan Wars and
the final border agreement with the Treaty of Bucharest in 1913, the
issue is continuously brought up at various times.
Before
the Second World War, when the powerless Communist Party of Greece
decided to become a member of the Communist International their
Bulgarian and Yugoslavian counterparts demanded as requirement for its
inclusion, to declare its agreement for the creation of an independent
communist state with the name Macedonia which it would had incorporated
the entire Northern Greece.
At
the end of the Second World War the communist Yugoslavia was formed and
Tito gave the name Macedonia to the southern part of his country that
until then it was known as Vardaska. Tito was hoping that in the future a
chance will present itself for the borders of his country to reach all
the way to the Aegean Sea.
Unfortunately
at the same time, Greece was embroiled in a bloody civil war, during
which all governments were besieging the western powers for their
support in the conflict. These western powers were unwilling to
displease Tito and Yugoslavia in expectation that he will break his
relations with Moscow that were not as cordial as other communist
states. For this reason the Greek governments never officially
complained while the international community was well aware that Tito by
using the name Macedonia was aiming at the creation of a "Macedonia of
the Aegean".
It
was during this period that the myth of the ancestry of the people of
Skopje from Alexander the Great was first created together with
irredentist ideas that have unfortunately become the prevailing ideology
with which several generations have been brought up. During the 1990's
when Yugoslavia was being partitioned the rhetoric from Skopje, with
support from the United States, developed a very aggressive character.
The United States saw Skopje and the geopolitical space as a chance for
further strategic control of the Balkans.
On
the Greek side, the all-powerful Orthodox Church, still trapped in the
mentality that Greeks are only those that identify as Orthodox, became
part of the problem and further blurred the issue by organizing massive
protests. Having wide coverage and unlimited access to the Greek media
it supplanted the Greek state in the eyes of the Greek people. This is
the same church for which the Roman Catholic Greeks of southern Italy,
the Muslim Pontians of the Black sea and the Kalash of Pakistan are not
part of the Greek Nation. Its rhetoric on the subject has nothing to do
with any sensibility for the promotion and protection of Hellenism
(which was always hostile to) but rather it is wasted in shows aimed for
internal consumption and the creation of a wider political sphere of
influence.
As
for the Greek State, its government and most of its political parties,
the sediment is that even a solution with a geographical qualifier that
includes the name Macedonia will suffice as long as the matter is
settled in a timely manner. This dismisses people of Hellenic ancestry
that still inhabit Skopje and more blatantly ignores the anti-Hellenic
propaganda and irredentist attitudes that certain circles coordinate
that ceaselessly claim that the capital of Skopje is Thessalonica.
If
the people of Skopje feel Macedonians they are automatically Hellenes
and the only realistic solution to the issue will be the bilateral and
peaceful unification of Skopje to Greece. If on the other hand they do
not want to be Greeks and do not wish to be part of a unified state then
let them chose a name that does not insult History, logic, and the
aesthetic sensibilities of educated people around the world.
Considering
the present circumstances the acceptance of any name with the
geographical, temporal, or any other prefix that uses the name Macedonia
(Northern, Upper, New , Slavo- etc) does not solve the problem but
rather complicates it and postpones for the future any real solution
with many negative consequences.
SUPREME COUNCIL OF ETHNIKOI HELLENES